Friday, March 29, 2013

The Doctrine Of Original Sin: Free Will or Free Choice?


Now to him who words , the wages are not
counted as grace but as debt. But to him
who does not work but believes on Him
who justifies the ungodly, his faith
is accounted for righteousness, just as
David also describes the blessedness
of the man to whom God imputes
righteousness apart from works:
“Blessed are those whose lawless
deeds are forgiven, and whole sins
are covered; blessed is the man to whom
the LORD shall not impute sin.”
Romans 4:4–8; cf. Psalm 32:1–2

            In our discussion of Original Sin, a theological doctrine given by the Early Church Fathers to account for sin and man’s inability to not sin we must address the dividing doctrine of Free Will. Free Will according to men such as Pelagius and Jacobus Arminius removes from man the doctrine of Original Sin which was passed down to Adam’s progeny. Yet it is this sin of Adam that affected both earth and the heavens that is why the universe groans for it is in turmoil (Romans 8:20–22). The sin of Adam had consequences far beyond what we can imagine for sin only existed with Satan, Lucifer, the angel that defied God and before man sin the only matter to be dealt with was Satan, and his legions of fallen angels. Satan fall did not affect the universe as did man’s for man willfully sinned against God in a manner that demanded justice for the world was made for man, not for angels, that is, not in the same way. Angels have a work to do in the realm of the universe and this work was to do the will of God, and yes, Satan willfully sinned, his pride, his ability to choose right from wrong was present when he sinned, but the world was for and is for man. God could have destroyed Satan and not have affected His glory for all other faithful angels would see that God was just in punishing Satan. Yet, for man it was different, for man was to live by faith in a physical real world that he was to rule and care for as his work in his eternal life. This Adam threw away and sinned against God and his eternal life. Now, all that was for man was to be affected and in each and every successive year from that point the earth began to groan under the pain of Adam’s sin affecting men who came after Adam, and God eventually dealt with man’s sin by global flood, destroying man, but saving Noah due to the faith of Noah in God, and obeying the command of God to build an ark, to believe in God that God would destroy the earth as then known and now, after the flood the earth having been reshaped, the atmosphere no longer separated by a water canopy, the earth was affected in a negative way: the earth groans to be what God had intended for it to be and will groan until God restores the earth by making it anew.
            The sin of Adam was due to his ability in his free will to choose and this he did without having an effect from sin, so he did it willingly knowing the will of God and willingly disobeyed God’s command. Pride, and a desire to do what his wife, Eve, asked of him and no longer believed that God could restore even for him a woman who would be faithful, he was afraid of losing what he had. This then made cause for heredity corruption and a lose of those ornaments that God gave to the first pair, first to Adam and passed on to Eve, the ornament of wisdom, virtue, truth, justice, and holiness and all was now substituted by dire pests, blindness, impotence, vanity, impurity, and unrighteousness, plunged his posterity into the same wretchedness. Satan knew all this but wanted by his pride and desire to have what God had, the universe and worship of man, hid all this from the first pair and deceptively deceived Eve, but Adam, Adam sinned outright and having walked with God, and talked with God, knowing that God created him and all that was, cast upon his posterity Original Sin a sin man could not of himself remove. But, not all believe this as a British Monk taught something far different and his teaching has been divisive in the Christian community even affecting Jacobus Arminius who has influenced those Churches who claim Christianity but teach that man could save himself and that there is no Original Sin that was caused by Adam and Adam’s posterity. So, I will give one such saying from Pelagius and then in the next blogs will discuss this even more.


“In the manner of good–for nothing and haughty servants, we cry out against the face of God and say, ‘It is hard, it is difficult, we cannot do it, we are but men, we are encompassed by frail flesh!’ [“The argument of the Gnostics] What blind madness! What unholy foolhardiness! We accuse God of a twofold lack of knowledge, so that he appears not to know what he has done, and not to know what he has commanded; as if, forgetful of the human frailty of which he is himself the author, he has imposed on man commands which he cannot bear. And, at the same time, oh horror!, we ascribe iniquity to the righteous and cruelty to the holy, while complaining, first, that he has commanded something impossible, secondly, that man is to be damned by him for doing things which he was unable to avoid, so that God –– and this is something which even to suspect is sacrilege – seems to have sought not so much our salvation as our punishment!” Pelagius (The Letters of Pelagius and his Followers by B.R. Rees, p. 53, published by The Boydell Press). Retrieved from the Internet: http://www.libraryoftheology.com/writings/freewill/Early_Church_on_Free_Will.pdf: March 29, 2013

Pelagius (fl. c. 390-418) was an ascetic who opposed the idea of predestination and asserted a strong version of the doctrine of free will. He was accused by Augustine of Hippo and others of denying the need for divine aid in performing good works. For him (according to them), the only grace necessary was the declaration of the law; humans were not wounded by Adam's sin and were perfectly able to fulfill the law apart from any divine aid. He denied the more specific doctrine of original sin as developed by Augustine. Pelagius was declared a heretic by the Council of Carthage
            I will close this blog with this to jar your thinking: “Behold, I was brought forth in iniquity, and in sin my mother conceived me. Behold, You desire truth in the inward parts, and in the hidden part You will make me to know wisdom” (Psalm 51:5–6.


Create in me a clean heart,
O God,
And renew a steadfast
            Spirit within me.
Do no cast me away from
            Your presence,
And do not take Your
            Holy Spirit from me.
                        Psalm 51:10–11

God Desires Your Faith: He Gave It To You As A Free Gift

Richard L. Crumb

No comments:

Post a Comment