Friday, April 5, 2013

The Soul: Immediatly Created; or, Generated By Parents?


But you have not so learned Christ,

if indeed you have heard Him,

as the truth is in Jesus: that you

put off, concerning your former

conduct, the old man which grows

corrupt according to the deceitful lusts,

and be renewed in the spirit of your mind,

and that you put on the new man which

was created according to God, in true

righteousness and holiness.

Ephesians 4:20–24



            I begin with the above Scripture to remind us that we are to learn Jesus Christ for in Him is truth. We are to put off the ‘old man” and put on the “new man” which is from and by God and in which dwells righteousness and holiness. Sin drove a wedge between God and man for God is Holy, Just, and demands from His creation the worship which is due Him as our creator. Man has this need even though some would reject this need so that they can continue in their deceitful lusts, but there is this sin that they must acknowledge and in their autonomous ways they ignore this fact, or tacitly agree that sin exists but will not do anything that will keep them from this antinomian life. There are those men who search for answers about life, sin, the origin of the soul, and they seek a way back to God only they have not learned Jesus Christ for they follow after philosophies that suit their presuppositions as to who God is, why things exist, especially man, and develop elaborate theologies to prove their point: They have not learned Jesus Christ. I have given some information as to what some have devised in regards to the origin of the soul: i.e., preexistence of the soul, and Origen’s theology as to preexistence of the soul and metempsychosis or an endless transmutation of the soul, a doctrine never accepted by the Church. I speak of important question in regard to the origin of the soul as to whether or not the soul is immediately created, or, whether it is generated by the parents (Traducianism). When it is spoken of the soul being immediately created there is a term used; Creationism, when we speak of the soul being generated by parents we use the term; Traducianism, which I will elaborate on so as to learn what the Bible says about these questions. The Greek Church favored creationism as the true nature of the soul. The Latin Church with Tertullian as a major theologian held to a theology of materialism, that is by the use of the language of materialism the soul was as much begotten as the body. Jerome (347 A.D.–420 A.D.) who was a Roman Christian priest, confessor, and theologian as well as historian and who became a Doctor of the Church opposed this doctrine that the soul was begotten when the physical body was begotten and held to the doctrine of creationism. Augustine  (354 A.D. –430 A.D.) was adverse to this doctrine but in his argument with Pelagius of the propagation of sin he became to favor the theory of Traduction, but could not fully receive this doctrine. Creationism became subsequently the almost universally received doctrine of the Latin Church. The Reformation of the Protestants adhered to the same doctrine. During the seventeenth century the Lutheran Church adopted the theory of Traduction even though earlier they favored creationism. Among many of the Reformed theologians, Calvin, Beza, Turrettin, and others, were creationists. In recent times German theologians are inclined to realism in any form, and in some manner have become advocates of Traducianism, although this is not the universal opinion of the German philosophers. We therefore must examine both Traducianism, and Creationism so that we can see what is true according to Scripture. This will be the thrust of the next blogs starting next week.

            Until we take the time to investigate these theories take the time to examine your own opinion(s) about these theories. Take a look at your Church and even ask the pastor questions on this matter so that you can understand what your Church’s opinion and position is on this subject. Read your Bible, do word studies on the soul which is a good way to know Scriptures. It is a good way to learn Jesus Christ and the truth. The apostle Paul gave us much to ponder and it would be good to record here what we need to learn: “And He Himself gave some to be apostles, some prophets, some evangelists, and some pastors and teachers, for the equipping of the saints for the work of ministry, for the edifying of the body of Christ, till we all come to the unity of the faith and of the knowledge of the Son of God, to a perfect man, to the measure of the stature of the fullness of Christ; that we should no longer be children, tossed to and fro and carried about with every wind of doctrine, by the trickery of men, in the cunning craftiness of deceitful plotting, but, speaking the truth in love, may grow up in all things into Him who is the hear––Christ––….” (Ephesians 4:11–15.

May Sunday, the Christian Sabbath, Be A Day Of Rest

Richard L. Crumb




Thursday, April 4, 2013

Is The Soul Eternal Being Anterior To Creation Of Man?


And the LORD God formed man
Of the dust of the ground, and breathed
Into his nostrils the breath of life;
And man became a living soul…..
And the LORD God caused a deep sleep
To fall on Adam, and he slept; and He took
One of his ribs, and closed up the flesh in its place.
Then the rib which the LORD God had taken
From man He made into a woman, and He
Brought to the man.
Genesis 2:7,21–22

            Preexistence makes cause for many questions; i.e., when was the soul created, or is the soul a god and is an eternal being, or does the soul have as one of its attributes that the soul is to be of the same essence as the Father God, and if God, as the Mormons teach is anthropomorphic, is the soul anthropomorphic, etc.? The Platonic and Realistic theories do not allow for God to have in His mind, as does an artist when about to paint a picture, a conception of that which He is about to make. These are two different theories. It is only a figure of speech to say that a picture exists as a conception in the artist’s mind. If the beginning foundation of a doctrine is built on falsehood, then even when it is seen as though it had validity, it does not, for nothing good can come from that which is bad; that is unless God changes it, and God never says anything about conceptions that are to be changed, rather God will change the soul by giving to man, a living soul, the gift of faith by means of the free gift of faith. Now man can think and act differently, and can by the guidance of the Holy Spirit do those things which God by His Providence gives to man to do. Even when the word “Christian” is attached to a doctrine it does mean that the doctrine is valid in the eyes of God. To seek the origin of the soul is to attempt to find answers and the Platonic, and Realist look outside of the reveal God in His Word, the Holy Bible to find answers by reason and rationale. Many Christian Theologians were influenced by Neoplatonism and this philosophy can be found in their theologies, and in their writings.
            I spoke in earlier blogs in regards to Neoplatonism a system developed in Alexandria in the third century by Plotinus and others who attempted to syncretize Christian concepts, some Judaism concepts with elements of mysticism and posited that there was a single source from which all existence emanates and by which an individual soul can be mystically united with that single source. This philosophical system greatly influenced one of the first theologians, Origen (184/185 A.D.–253/254 A.D.) who lived in Alexandria and heard Ammonius Saccus possibly and knew Plotinus possibly, however, Origen did not teach true Platonic philosophy of an ideal world, a dualism which was enhanced and even refuted in some ways by Neoplatonists for Origen he supposed that the souls of men had a separate, conscious, personal existence in a previous state ( as do Mormons), furthermore these preexistent souls sinned or at least in a state of sin and then are condemned to a physical body. Origen taught a theology of an eternal creation. That is, this present state of being is only one epoch, an era in the existence of the human soul. The soul has passed through several, of not many, other epochs and even were in other forms of existence, and will go through other epochs and forms in the future. This is what the Orientals, Buddhists, Hinduism teaches, and has taught for many centuries. This is to teach a doctrine of metempsychosis, a transmigration of the soul. This doctrine of an endless transmutation of the soul has never been adopted in the Christian Church, it can be said that it began with Origen and ended with the death of Origen as it was rejected by both Greeks and Latins, yet there are those who have attempted in some form of this theory to resurrect it and teach it to their parishioners. This doctrine does not pretend to have Scriptural support, or to be Scriptural for the Bible never speaks of a creation of men before Adam, or that the soul was anterior to the creation of Adam. That man, or the soul that according to the above theory that says that the soul was in some sort of state to be in sin and was placed due to that sin in a physical body. Scripture only states as the opening Scripture testifies to, that our soul was placed in man by God and that the soul was not in sinfulness prior to Adam’s fall in sin. It is by our first parents that sin came into the world. It is presumption to say that all souls were created before the creation of man, that the soul was in some sort of unconscious state and then were awaken and placed into the physical body of man.
            This then leads us back to the original subject of the doctrine of Original Sin. Further questions are such as; how is it that the soul is in sin, and was our sin generated and passed on to their progeny by their sinful act? Before we continue on the subject of Original Sin we must attend to the other doctrines or theories in regards to the soul. The next blog will begin a discussion of the theory of Tradcianism and whether or not it is a Scriptural theory and how the Church approach this doctrine or theory. Important are these questions as to whether or not the soul was created, or whether it is simply generated by the parents. How the soul came to be in man is so important. Stay with me as the answer is one of more than the generation of the soul, it has to do with salvation and the regeneration of man as God created, a perfect man, a man that sinned, and how we by repentance can come to be a child of God.

When I was a child,
            I spoke as a child,
I understand as a child,
            I thought as a child;
But when I became a man,
            I put away childish things.
                                    1Corinthians 13:11

Do not rejoice in iniquity: shun the world’s promotion of sin

Richard L. Crumb

 



Wednesday, April 3, 2013

Did The Soul Preexist Anterior To Creation?


And do not fear those who kill the body
But cannot kill the soul. But rather
Fear Him who is able to destroy
Both soul and body in hell.
Are not two sparrows sold for
A copper coin? And not one of them
Falls to the ground apart from your
Father’s will. But the very hairs
Of your head are all numbered.
Do not fear therefore; you are of
More value than many sparrows.
Matthew 10:28–30

            In the previous blog I began this investigation into the origin of the soul and then in future blogs will continue the doctrine of Original Sin and how Scriptures approaches this subject and gives the Father’s word revealing the true doctrine of Original Sin. I must show how this doctrine of preexistence, one of the three theories presented to people is being taught in certain religious circles: i.e., Mormons is one of such who teach preexistence:
Consistent with the idea that all spirits (or souls) existed prior to their mortal life, LDS doctrine holds that all vegetable and animal life was created spiritually before the physical creation (Moses 3:5; cf. Gen. 2:5). In this sense, every living thing (plant, animal, human) is spoken of as having a soul (Moses 3:9, 19).
The human soul is innately endowed with an agency that should be honored and guarded as sacred and eternal (D&C 134:4). The soul (spirit), being eternal, cannot be fully destroyed but can suffer a type of destruction or spiritual death through sins that result in total and ultimate estrangement from God (1 Ne. 14:3; Alma 12:16-18, 36;30:47;42:9, 16). Scripture teaches that all human souls are children of God and are of infinite worth (Matt. 16:26; Alma 39:17; D&C 18:10-16). God has great joy in a repentant soul, and there is no more important work than the saving of souls and bringing them to God (D&C 18:10-16;15:6;16:6). RICHARD N. WILLIAMS[1]
            When there is a teaching that holds to preexistence of the soul there can be found other teachings that are not orthodox, rather they hold to a god that is not as the Bible portrays and reveals God:

The traditional Mormon view of God is summed up by the famous Lorenzo Snow couplet, "As man is God once was, as God is man may be." The historic understanding of this strongly implies that God the Father was once a sinner, and that we ourselves may model our mortal experience unto godhood after the mortal experience he once participated in. In his famous "King Follett Discourse" Joseph Smith taught,
"God himself was once as we are now, and is an exalted man, and sits enthroned in yonder heavens. That is the great secret... [Y]ou have got to learn how to be Gods yourselves, and to be kings and priests to God, the same as all Gods have done before you..."[2]
In the book; A Compilation containing the Lectures on Faith; by Orson Pratt ( a Mormon) as given at Kirtland Ohio even goes so far as to say that God needed faith to create:
15. By this we understand that the principle of power which existed in the bosom of God, by which the worlds were framed, was faith; and that it is by reason of this principle of power existing in the Deity, that all created things exist; so that all things in heaven, on earth, or under the earth exist by reason of faith as it existed in Him.[3]
            According to Mormon doctrine and teachings the soul existed, that is was anterior to creation of the physical body, and that God by means of His faith, which in some way He needed, and this would be counted true if God was as a man which the Mormons teach, to create. There is no Scripture that indicates these facts as proposed by the Mormons.
            In the next blog I will attempt to bring light on the teaching of Origen an early Church father that had a great impact on Christianity today, who taught a preexistence albeit no the Platonic doctrine of the ideal world. Should we hold to this teaching? Read the next blog and make this decision for yourself.

A good man obtains favor
            From the LORD,
But a man of wick intentions
            He will condemn.
                        Proverbs 12:2

Take Time Today: Read God’s Word

Richard L. Crumb


[1] Retrieved from: http://eom.byu.edu/index.php/Soul: April 3, 2013
[2] Retrieved from: http://www.mrm.org/god-of-mormonism: April 3, 2013
[3] Pratt, Orson; A Compilation containing the Lectures on Faith as delivered at the School of the Prophets at Kirtland, Ohio, Bookcraft, Inc. Salt Lake City, Utah; p. 8